Madonna and Child with Saints Francis and Jerome and a Devout Woman
(Serina c. 1480 - Venice 1528)
The painting addresses the theme of the so-called Sacra Conversazione (Sacred Conversation), a subject that enjoyed great success in the Veneto area in the first decades of the 16th century. The panel is traditionally ascribed to Negretti as part of his early output; however, it has been suggested that this attribution should be rejected and that the as-yet unidentified figure of the so-called Master of the Madonna of Chantilly be credited with it, along with other stylistically similar works.
Object details
Inventory
Location
Date
Classification
Period
Medium
Dimensions
Provenance
Rome, Borghese Collection, recorded in the Inventario Fidecommissario Borghese 1833, p. 12. Purchased by Italian State, 1902.
Exhibitions
- 2012 Illegio, Casa delle Esposizioni
Conservation and Diagnostic
- 1903 Luigi Bartolucci (pest control)
- 1936 Carlo Matteucci
- 1947 Carlo Matteucci
Work not currently exhibited
Commentary
The painting is mentioned in the Fideicommissary Inventory of 1833, where it is ascribed to Palma the Elder. Morelli (1876) considered it to be one of his early paintings while Venturi (1893) considered it to be one of the Veneto painter’s less successful efforts. Although considering it still stemming from ‘tradizioni paesane’ [country/provincial traditions], Longhi (1928) noted echoes of Titian in the work, especially in the background figures, placing its execution towards the end of the first decade of the 16th century, a date generally accepted by later critics. In view of the painting’s high quality, Longhi rejected the hypothesis put forward by Cavalcaselle (1864), who believed it to be the work of Cariani, and he ruled out the attribution to an anonymous figure close to Palma the Elder and active in Venice in the same years. In line with this reading, Della Pergola (1655) reiterated the authorship of the painting that had been called into question by Gombosi (1932), who assigned it to Francesco di Simone, emphasising its affinities with the Sacred Conversation at the Musée Condé in Chantilly. Indeed, with this work, the Borghese panel shares the compositional cut and the arrangement of the figures in space, in particular that of the donor placed in foreshortening ‘in the wings’, figures that led Della Pergola to consider both paintings as ex-votos produced at approximately the same time. Mariacher (1968) excluded the work from the catalogue of the Master of Serina, ascribing its execution to his workshop, while Rylands (1988) included it in a group of paintings imputable to a minor artist of Palma’s circle called the Master of the Madonna of Chantilly. The scholar also reported Garas’ (1985) assertion that the panel had been in the Borghese collection since the 17th century, without, however, offering precise documentary evidence other than the attribution of the painting to Il Pordenone (Giovanni Antonio de’ Sacchis).
Ballarin (1965) emphasised that the panel’s layout was derived from Giovanni Bellini’s altarpiece in San Francesco della Vigna, on account of the presence of the two saints generally identified as St. Francis and St. Jerome, on either side of the Madonna and Child, with the donor in the foreground. Allusions to Titian and Lorenzo Lotto (see Savy 2013), coupled with the Bellini source, are indicative of Palma the Elder’s style in the second decade of the 16th century, the period to which this Sacred Conversation is also dated.
Elisa Martini
Bibliography
- F. Kugler, Handbuch der Geschichte der Malerei, Stuttgart 1847, II, p. 34.
- J.A. Crowe, G.B. Cavalcaselle, A History of Painting in North Italy, London 1864-1866, IV, 1864, p. 532.
- G. Morelli, Die Galerien Roms: I. Die Galerie Borghese: ein kritischer Versuch von Iwan Lermolieff, in “Zeitschrift für bildende Kunst”, 10, 1876, p. 137.
- A. Venturi, Il Museo e la Galleria Borghese, Roma 1893, p. 107.
- G. Frizzoni, Eine neue Photogrphische Publikation der Galerie Borghèse in Rome, in “Zeitschrift für bildende Kunst”, IV, 1894, p. 61.
- H. Ulmann, Il Museo e la Galleria Borghese per Adolfo Venturi, in “Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft”, XVII, 1894, p. 163.
- B. Berenson, The Venetian painters of the Renaissance: with an index to their works, New York 1906, p. 119.
- D. von Hadeln, Über einige Frühwerke des Palma Vecchio, in “Monatshefte für Kunstwissenschaft”, 4, 1911, p. 226.
- A. Foratti, I Polittici Palmeschi di Dossena e Serina, in “L’Arte”, XIV, 1911, p. 41.
- W. Suida, Ein Meisterwerk des Palma Vecchio, in “Belvedere”, 9/10, 1926, 8, p. 127.
- R. Longhi, Precisioni nelle Gallerie Italiane, I, La R. Galleria Borghese, Roma 1928, pp. 46, 193.
- G. Gombosi, Les origines artistiques de Palma Vecchio, in “Gazette des beaux-arts”, 8, 1932, p. 175.
- A. Spahn, Palma Vecchio, Leipzig 1932, p. 187.
- B. Berenson, Pitture Italiane del Rinascimento: catalogo dei principali artisti e delle loro opere con un indice dei luoghi, trad. di E. Cecchi, Milano 1936, p. 163.
- A. De Rinaldis, Catalogo della Galleria Borghese in Roma, Roma 1948, p. 90.
- P. della Pergola, Itinerario della Galleria Borghese, Roma 1951, p. 14.
- P. della Pergola, La Galleria Borghese. I Dipinti, I, Roma 1955, p. 124, n. 224, fig. 226.
- A. Ballarin, Palma il Vecchio (I Maestri del colore, 64), Milano 1965, p. 4.
- R. Longhi, Edizione delle opere complete. II. Saggi e ricerche 1925-1928, 2 voll., Firenze 1967, I, pp. 283-284, 341.
- G. Mariacher, Palma il Vecchio, Milano 1968, p. 133, cat. 67.
- G. Robertson, Giovanni Bellini, Oxford 1968, p. 13, nota 4.
- S.J. Freedberg, Painting in Italy: 1500 to 1600, Harmondsworth 1971, p. 104.
- F. Rossi, Bergamo e Palma il Vecchio; un rapporto dialettico, in Serina a Palma il Vecchio: nel quinto centenario della nascita 1480-1980, a cura di G. Labaa, Serina 1981, p. 36.
- S. Ringbom, Icon to narrative: The rise of the dramatic close-up in fifteenth-century devotional painting, Doornspijk 1984, pp. 77-79, 90-93.
- K. Garas, Musici, adultere e conversioni: la “fortuna” del Pordenone nel collezionismo europeo tra Sei e Settecento, in Il Pordenone, atti del convegno internazionale di studio (Pordenone, 23-25 agosto 1984), a cura di C. Furlan, Pordenone 1985, p. 112.
- P. Rylands, Palma il Vecchio: l’opera completa, Milano 1988, p. 290, cat. A.57 .
- A. Coliva, Galleria Borghese, Roma 1994, p. 64.
- K. Herrmann Fiore, Museo e Galleria Borghese. Roma scopre un tesoro. Dalla pinacoteca ai depositi un museo che non ha più segreti, San Giuliano Milanese 2006, p. 57.
- B.M. Savy, Negretti, Jacopo, detto Palma il Vecchio, in Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, 78, 2013
- J. Ferdinand, in I Bambini e il Cielo, catalogo della mostra (Illegio, Casa delle Esposizioni, 2012), a cura di S. Castri, Torino 2012, pp. 235-236, cat. 53.