Portrait of a Man
(Urbino 1483 - Rome 1520)
The picture shows the head and upper body of a man, depicted in front pose. His head is almost imperceptibly turned to the right in contrast to the direction of his gaze, and he wears a black robe. The face, framed by long hair and topped by a wide black cap, stands out against the blue sky, while the landscape in the background is barely visible. The work, attributed to Holbein in the 1833 fideicommissary list, was not in its current state: the figure wore a different, wider headdress and a heavy fur tunic open over a shirt trimmed with lace. Attributed first to Perugino, then to Raphael and Pinturicchio, the panel was restored in 1911; it was freed of considerable overpainting and repainting, which fortunately preserved the face and its remarkable nuances. Even today, the subject, thought by some to be a self-portrait by Perugino or Serafino Aquilano, has not been identified. The debate is still ongoing, basically dividing critics between whether it should be attributed to Raphael or his master Pietro Perugino.
Object details
Inventory
Location
Date
Classification
Period
Medium
Dimensions
Provenance
Borghese Collection, recorded in the Inventario Fidecommissario Borghese 1833. Purchased by Italian State, 1902.
Exhibitions
- 1930 Londra
- 1938 Belgrado
- 1954-1955 Bruxelles, Palais des Beaux-Arts
- 1983 Città di Castello
- 1984 Roma, Palazzo Venezia
- 1992 Torre dei Passeri, Castello Gizzi, Casa di Dante in Abruzzo
- 2002-2003 Roma, Galleria Borghese
- 2003-2004 Perugia, Galleriaa Nzionale dell’Umbria
- 2006 Roma, Galleria Borghese
- 2011 Forlì, Musei di San Domenico
- 2011-2012 Monaco, Alte Pinakothek
- 2012 Pechino, Museo Thien'an Men
Conservation and Diagnostic
- 1903 Luigi Bartolucci (pest control)
- 1911 Luigi Cavenaghi (restoration)
- 1983 Sebastiano Sciuti, Corrado Maltese (diagnostics)
- 2000 Department of Imaging Diagnostics at the European Hospital in Rome (diagnostics); Editech (diagnostics)
- 2002 Elisabetta Zatti (restoration)
- 2019 IFAC-CNR; Bruker Nano Analitics (diagnostics)
Work not currently exhibited
Commentary
The provenance of the painting is unknown. It might be identifiable as one described in an inventory dated 1700 which refers to the paintings in the ground floor apartment of Prince Borghese at the Palazzo di Ripetta. It mentions a portrait ‘by Pietro Perugino painted by Raphael’ (De Rinaldis 1936; Della Pergola 1959). It has also been hypothesised (Della Pergola 1959; Barberini, in Raffaello nelle raccolte Borghese, 1984; Marcelli, in Perugino 2004; Zalabra, in Melozzo da Forlì, 2011) that it may have come from the Aldobrandini collection. This theory, however, does not seem to tie in with the 1700 reference, given that the Aldobrandini primogeniture was only acquired by the second-born Borghese after 1767. In 1794, Vasi mentioned seeing in the mezzanine floors of Prince Aldobrandini in Palazzo Borghese ‘a portrait, by Pietro Perugino’ (Vasi 1794; Della Pergola 1959).
The panel can only be identified with certainty starting with the Borghese fideicommissary list of 1833, where it was included among the masterpieces of the Flemish school in the collection as a painting by Holbein, together with another panel of the same size (respectively under nos. 18-19), now attributed to Hans Leonhard Schäufelein (inv. 287).
In 1869, Mündler (in Burckhardt 1869, p. 844), in his notes on Cicero, suggested that the portrait be attributed to Perugino, believing it to be ‘a beautiful self-portrait of the master’, prompting a debate on the subject and the painter of the panel that has never been fully settled. At the time, the panel did not look as it does today: the figure wore a different, wider headdress and a heavy fur tunic open over a shirt trimmed with lace, as documented in the photo in Venturi's catalogue (1893).
In 1885, Minghetti argued for recognising Raphael’s hand in the portrait, conjecturing that Pinturicchio was the subject depicted. Giovanni Morelli (1897) with a famous passage in which, in addition to praising the liveliness of the eyes and the splendour of the complexion, the poor condition of the panel was noted, firmly asserted that it be attributed to the Urbino master. This opinion was shared by the then director of the Gallery Giovanni Piancastelli, but not accepted by all the critics of the time, such as Venturi (1893), who continued to uphold the authorship of Perugino.
In 1911, due to severe deterioration in the portrait's paint surface, its restoration was begun and entrusted to Luigi Cavenaghi under the supervision of Giulio Cantalamessa. During the operation, the headdress, evidently larger in the underlying painting, and the fur tunic were removed. The result, which virtually corresponds to its current appearance, although impressive, did not prove to be conclusive in terms of attribution. Cantalamessa's opinion shifted in favour of Perugino's authorship, as did Venturi's (1913), even though numerous scholars supported Raphael: from Berenson (1932) to Longhi (1955), Della Pergola (1959) to Fischel (1962), Dussler (1966; 1971) to Herrmann Fiore (1992; 1997) and Ferino (1994), to name but a few.
Identifying the subject is also problematic. After Mündler’s earlier identification of the work as Perugino's self-portrait, disproved by the portrait at the Collegio del Cambio in Perugia, and the suggestion that it portrays the cantor Serafino Ciminelli, known as Serafino Aquilano (Venturi 1893), the identity of the subject, however, remains unknown.
Although compressed in a rigid frontal pose, accentuated by the small format, the remarkable three-dimensionality of the head powerfully contrasts with the flattening effect of the dark, gloomy robe, recalling the Urbino portraits of Guidobaldo da Montefeltro and Elisabetta della Rovere in the Uffizi, as well as echoes of Flemish painting typical of that cultural context.
The most recent analyses have also confirmed the very high quality of the face, which is the area most spared from repainting and therefore the most unblemished.
Over time, critics have generally tended to attribute the painting to Perugino (Scarpellini, 1984; Garibaldi, 1999; Meyer zu Capellen, 2008 Marcelli, in Perugino 2004; Pierini, 2023).
Although this work is indeed quite different from Raphael's early paintings, a comparison with ascertained works by Perugino such as the Portrait of Francesco delle Opere (Florence, Uffizi Galleries, inv. 1890, no. 1700) and the Self-portrait in Perugia (Nobile Collegio del Cambio) does not seem to settle the attribution question either, since there was a close bond between the two artists and they both worked in a milieu strongly marked by influences from beyond the Alps.
Marina Minozzi
Bibliography
- M. Vasi, Itinerario istruttivo di Roma o sia Descrizione generale delle opere più insigni di Pittura, Scultura e Architettura…, Roma 1794, to. II, p. 384
- O. Mündler in J. Burckhardt, Der Cicerone. Eine Anleitung zun Genuss der Kunstwerke Italiens, Leipzig 1869, III, p. 844
- G. Frizzoni, in Archivio Storico Italiano, 1879, IV-V, p. 270
- F. A. Gruyer, Raphaël peintre de Portraits, Paris 1881, I, p. 181
- F. Wickhoff, recensione a: J. A. Crowe, G. B. Cavalcaselle, Raphael: His Life and Works (1882), in Mittheilungen des Instituts für Österreichische Geschichtsforschungen, V, l, 1883, p. 180
- M. Minghetti, Raffaello, Bologna 1885, p. 49
- G. Morelli (J. Lermolieff), Le opere dei Maestri Italiani nelle Gallerie di Monaco, Dresa e Berlino (ed. italiana), Bologna 1886, p. 335
- W. von Seidlitz, Einige Taufen Lermolieff’s, in Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft, XIII, 1890, pp. 114-117, p. 115
- W. von Seidlitz, Raphael und Timoteo Viti. Nebst einem Ueberblick über Raphael Jugendentwicklung, in Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft, XIV, 1891, pp. 1-8 p. 7
- A. Venturi, Il Museo e la Galleria Borghese, Roma 1893, p. 191
- H. Ullmann, recensione a: A. Venturi, II Museo e la Galleria Borghese (1893), in Repertorium für Kunstwissenschaft, XVII, 1894, p. 161
- H. Koopmann, Raphaels Handzeichnungen in der Auffassung, Marburg 1897, pp. 483-485
- G. Morelli, Della Pittura Italiana. Studi Storici Critici: Le Gallerie Borghese e Doria Pamphili in Roma, (trad. G. Frizzoni) Milano 1897, p. 134
- A. Rosenberg, Raffael (Klassiker der Kunst), Stuttgart-Leipzig 1905 pp. 4; 145
- G. Urbini, Raffaello nell’Umbria, “Rassegna Nazionale”, 1° gennaio 1906 I, p. 36
- K. Woermann, Die Italienische Bildnismalerei der Renaissance. Führer zur Kunst (4), Esslingen 1906, p. 68
- F. Knapp, Perugino, (Künstlermonographien), Bielefeld-Leipzig 1907, pp. 71; 88-89
- A. Oppe, Raphaël, 1909, pp. 36; 226
- G. Frizzoni, Il ritrattino di Raffaello nella Galleria Borghese, in Rassegna d’Arte, XII, 1912, pp. 1-4
- E. Modigliani, Il Ritratto del Perugino della Galleria Borghese, in L’Arte, XV, 1912, p. 70
- A. Venturi, in Storia dell’arte italiana, 1913, VII-2, p. 508
- W. Bombe, Perugino. Des Meister Gemälde (Klassiker der Kunst), Stuttgart und Berlin 1914, p. XI
- C. Ricci, Raffaello Sanzio, 1920, p. 31
- K. Escher, Malerei der Renaissance in Mittel und Unteritalien, in Handbuch der Kunstwissenschaft, I, Leipzig 1922, II, p. 275
- U. Gnoli, Pietro Perugino, Spoleto 1923, p. 65
- G. Gronau, I ritratti di Guidobaldo da Montefeltro e di Elisabetta Gonzaga in Firenze, in bollettino d’Arte,1925, II, IV, p. 452
- R. Longhi, Precisioni nelle Gallerie Italiane, I: La R. Galleria Borghese, Roma 1928, p. 216
- A Commemorative Catalogue of the Exhibition of Italian Art 1930 (Edited by Lord Balniel and Kenneth Clark, in consultation with Ettore Modigliani), Oxford-London 1931, p. 135
- F. Canuti, Il Perugino, Siena 1931, p. 80
- B. Berenson, Italian Pictures of the The Renaissance, Oxford 1932, p. 482
- C. Gamba, Raphaël (tr. Alazard), Paris 1932, p. 30
- R. Offner, A portrait of Perugino by Raphaël, in The Burlington Magazine, LXV, 1934, p. 254
- A. De Rinaldis, Catalogo della Galleria Borghese, Roma 1937, p. 19
- O. Fischel, in Thieme-Becker, 1935, XXIX, p. 435
- B. Berenson, Pitture Italiane del Rinascimento (tr. E. Cecchi), Milano 1936, p. 414
- A. De Rinaldis, Documenti inediti per la storia della R. Galleria Borghese in Roma. II una inedita nota settecentesca delle opere pittoriche nel palazzo Borghese in Campo Marzio, in Archivi, pp. 194-206, p. 200
- V. Golzio, Raffaello nei documenti, nelle testimoniante dei contemporanei e nella letteratura del suo secolo, Città del Vaticano 1936, p. 364
- Mostra del Ritratto Italiano nei secoli, Belgrado 1938, p. 26
- E. Waldmann, Raffael. Fresken, Gemälde, Zeichnungen, Burg b. M, 1940, pp. 4, 8, tav. 27
- A. Bertini Calosso, Ritratti e Madonne di Raffaello, Novara 1941
- W. Suida, Raphael, London 1941, (2a ed. 1948), pp. 7, 23, tav. 15
- S. Ortolani, Raffaello, Bergamo 1942, p. 18, tav. 13
- A. De Rinaldis, Catalogo della Galleria Borghese, Bologna 1948, p. 34
- O. Fischel, Raphaël (ed. ingl.), London 1948, I, pp. 55-56, 358
- S. Ortolani, Raffaello (1942), Bergamo 1948 (3° ed.), p. 26
- C. Gamba, Pittura Umbra del Rinascimento. Raffaello, Novara 1949, p. XLVII, tav. 49
- P. Della Pergola, La Galleria Borghese in Roma, Milano 1950, p. 33
- L'Europe humaniste, catalogo della mostra, (Bruxelles, Palais des Beaux-Arts, 15.12.1954-28.2.1955), Bruxelles 1954, p. 84
- M. Pittaluga, Raffaello. Dipinti su tavola, Milano 1955 (2° ed.), p. 10
- E. Camesasca, Tutta la pittura di Raffaello, Milano 1956 pp. 20, 36, 96
- L. Ferrara, Galleria Borghese, Novara 1956p. . 56
- P. Della Pergola, Galleria Borghese. I dipinti, II, Roma 1959, pp. 113-114, n. 168
- M. Valsecchi, Raffaello, Milano 1960 p. 13
- O. Fischel, Raphael, Berlin 1962, p. 40
- L. Dussler, Raffael. Kritisches Verzeichnis der Gemälde, Wandbilder und Bildteppiche , München 1966, p. 64
- P.L. De Vecchi, L’opera completa di Raffaello, Milano 1966, p. 90
- L. Ferrara, La Galleria Borghese, Novara 1970, p. 48
- A.P. Oppè, Raphael, London 1970, p. 31
- L. Dussler, Raphael. A critical catalogue of his pictures, wall-paintings and tapestries, London 1971, p. 8
- W. Kelber, Raphael von Urbino: Leben und Werk, Stuttgart 1979p. , 417
- M.G. Barberini, in Raffaello nelle raccolte Borghese, catalogo della mostra, (Roma, Galleria Borghese, gennaio-marzo 1984), Roma 1984, pp. 28-32
- P. Scarpellini, Perugino, Milano 1984, pp. 79-80, n. 35
- G. Morelli, Della pittura italiana studi storico-critici, a cura di J. Anderson, Milano 1991, pp. 148-150
- K. Herrmann Fiore, in Raffaello e Dante, catalogo della mostra, a cura di C. Gizzi (Casa di Dante in Abruzzo, Castello Gizzi, Torre de’ Passeri (PE), 26 settembre - 30 novembre 1992) Milano 1992, p. 263
- S. Ferino, Raffaello alla Borghese, in Galleria Borghese, a cura di A. Coliva, Roma 1994, pp. 252-269, p. 260
- P. De Vecchi, Raffaello: la mimesi, l’armonia e l’invenzione, Firenze 1995, p. 250
- K. Herrmann Fiore, Guida alla Galleria Borghese, Roma 1997, p. 67
- V. Garibaldi, Perugino. Catalogo completo, Firenze 1999, p. 105, n. 14
- C. Stefani, in Galleria Borghese 2000, p. 222
- J. Meyer zur Capellen, Raphael. A Critical Catalogue of His Paintings, III, 2008, p. 225, X-20
- F. Marcelli, in Perugino, il divin pittore, catalogo della mostra, a cura di V. Garibaldi, F.F. Mancini, (Perugia, Galleria Nazionale dell’Umbria, 28 febbraio-28 luglio 2004), Milano 2004, pp. 248-249, n. I.39
- M. Minozzi, in Raffaello. Da Firenze a Roma, catalogo della mostra, a cura di A. Coliva, (Roma, Galleria Borghese, 19 maggio - 27 agosto 2006), Ginevra-Milano 2006, n. 1; Herrmann Fiore 2006, pp. 112-113, n. 1
- F. Zalabra, in Melozzo da Forlì, catalogo della mostra, (Forlì) Milano 2011, p. 280, n. 73
- M. Onali, in Perugino e Raffaello. Modelli nobili per Sassoferrato a Perugia, catalogo della mostra (Perugia, Nobile Collegio del Cambio 22 giugno- 20 ottobre 2013), a cura di F.F. Mancini, A. Natali, Aguapiano, Perugia 2013, pp. 176-179
- A. Melograni, Per non ricordare invano. Il ‘Diario’ di Pasquale Rotondi e la corrispondenza con i colleghi delle Soprintendenze e la Direzione Generale delle Arti (1940- 1946), in Bollettino d’Arte, 27, 2015, pp. 115-200 pp. 137; 155;184; 196; 198
- M. Pierini, Perugino: il volto, il ritratto, in Il meglio maestro d’Italia. Perugino e il suo tempo, catalogo della mostra, a cura di M. Pierini. V. Picchiarelli, (Perugia, Galleria Nazionale dell’Umbria 4 marzo-11 giugno 2023) Milano 2023, pp. 384-389 p. 389
- R. Alberti, T. Frizzi, M. Gironda, M. Occhipinti, T. Parsani, C. Seccaroni, Ritratto d’uomo: lettura delle mappe di concentrazione degli elementi ottenute con la tecnica MA-XRF, in Raffaello nella Galleria Borghese 2023, pp. 136-141
- C. Cucci, F. Cherubini, M. Picollo, C. Seccaroni, Ritratto d’uomo: underdrawing, in Raffaello nella Galleria Borghese 2023, pp. 130-135
- M. Minozzi, La Deposizione Borghese e un nuovo progetto di indagine di conservazione preventiva, in Raffaello nella Galleria Borghese. Nuove indagini e un progetto di conservazione programmata, a cura di M. Minozzi e S. Ciofetta, Cinisello Balsamo 2023, pp. 21-39, pp. 34-36